Research Finder
Find by Keyword
Did One Weekend Leave America With (Still) Only One Launch Provider?
Starship catches its upper stage, Vulcan loses 40 Amazon Leo satellites, and BE-4 questions shadow Blue Origin New Glenn while Rocket Lab Neutron waits for 2027.
11/17/2026
Key Highlights
- SpaceX's Starship Flight 15 deployed 26 Starlink V3 satellites, adding up to roughly 26 Tbps of capacity. SpaceX says that equals the capacity of about ten Falcon 9 Starlink launches.
- Ship 42 became the first Starship upper stage caught by the launch tower, after about 22 hours in orbit, while the Super Heavy booster called off its catch and splashed down in the Gulf.
- ULA's Vulcan failed about 10 minutes into its return-to-flight mission and lost 40 Amazon Leo satellites, the company's first total mission failure since it was formed in 2006.
- Early reporting says Vulcan's two BE-4 engines burned at least 30 seconds longer than planned, and the Centaur upper stage made abnormal corrections. Two months before launch, the engines had been retrofitted with the oxygen valve fix linked to Blue Origin's own New Glenn May explosion.
- We expect ULA to survive as a government-anchored provider that keeps the Pentagon's second launch option alive. For now, the larger risk is that two of the three US alternatives to SpaceX Falcon 9 depend on one engine.
The News
SpaceX's Starship Flight 15 deployed 26 Starlink V3 satellites on 13 November, and the next day it completed the first tower catch of a Starship upper stage, while the Super Heavy booster called off its catch and splashed down in the Gulf. On 15 November, United Launch Alliance's Vulcan failed about 10 minutes into its return-to-flight mission, losing 40 Amazon Leo satellites in the first total mission failure since ULA's 2006 founding. Early reporting points to a first-stage burn that ran long on the Blue Origin BE-4 engines and to unusual Centaur upper stage behavior. That is an open question for New Glenn, which flies seven BE-4s and is targeting a return to flight around the turn of the year. The weekend leaves the US medium and heavy launch market more dependent on SpaceX at a time when launch capacity is getting tight, which sharpens the timing question for Rocket Lab's Neutron, according to Spaceflight Now.
Analyst Take
The weekend handed the market an easy story. SpaceX caught a Starship upper stage at the tower for the first time, and less than a day later United Launch Alliance lost a Vulcan and 40 Amazon Leo satellites on a flight meant to end a nine-month grounding. Winner, loser, move on. We think that framing misses the more durable finding. The strongest case for calm runs like this: if the root cause sits in the Centaur upper stage, the BE-4 engine is clean, New Glenn is unaffected, and ULA's problem is execution on one vehicle rather than anything systemic. That case deserves a hearing because it may very well prove correct. But even then, two of the three US heavy-lift paths outside SpaceX still run on one engine, from one supplier, carrying one recently modified oxygen valve. Any CIO who has built a dual-vendor strategy only to discover both vendors bought the same chipset knows the feeling. Redundancy on paper is not redundancy in the supply chain.
What Was Announced
SpaceX Starship Flight 15 lifted off from Starbase on 13 November and began deploying its 26 Starlink V3 satellites about 35 to 40 minutes into flight. Each V3 is designed to deliver about 1 Tbps of downlink, so the batch represents up to roughly 26 Tbps of new constellation capacity, which SpaceX describes as about ten times what a Falcon 9 load of V2 Mini satellites adds. That distinction matters for how this flight gets described. By satellite count, 26 V3s is about one Falcon 9 load, since Falcon 9 routinely flies 24 to 29 V2 Minis. The tenfold gain is in capacity, and it comes from the satellite as much as the rocket. A fully loaded Starship is intended to carry about 60 V3s, which SpaceX frames as more than 20 times a Falcon 9 Starlink mission. V3 is too large for a Falcon 9 fairing, so its deployment depends entirely on Starship.
The more consequential event came the next day, when Ship 42 returned after about 22 hours in orbit and was caught by the tower. Booster reuse is already proven. The upper stage is where the throwaway cost still sits, and recovering it intact is what lets each Starship flight become inspection and refurbishment rather than new hardware. The Super Heavy booster called off its own catch and ditched in the Gulf, a reminder that a fully reused system has to work on both ends, every time. SpaceX said the booster's guidance, navigation, and control (GNC) system detected that it was out of position for a catch and steered it offshore, where its flight termination system fired as designed. Elon Musk attributed the shortfall to slight engine underperformance that left the booster low on propellant.
Vulcan's flight packed an unusual number of firsts into a return-to-flight mission. It was the first VC6 configuration with six solid boosters, the first with the shortened, LEO-optimized Centaur V, and the first vehicle stacked in a new integration facility. The solids appear to have performed normally and separated around 1 minute 40 seconds. That was a relief, since nozzle problems on the Northrop Grumman solids were a key cause of the nine-month grounding. Ars Technica, citing people familiar with the flight, reports that the two BE-4 engines fired at least 30 seconds past their planned shutdown, separation came late, and the vehicle began to spin, while telemetry showed unusual Centaur orientation corrections early in its burn. ULA CEO Mark Peller said Blue Origin had retrofitted the engines with its oxygen valve fix about two months before launch. ULA has not named a cause.
Market Analysis
Start with ULA's survival. The bear case is straightforward. ULA targeted 16 to 18 Vulcan flights in 2026 and flew two. The Space Force has kept national security missions off Vulcan since February and has already moved work to SpaceX, including the final GPS III satellite. Now the company has lost a commercial payload outright. We still expect ULA to survive, for a reason the commercial market does not price. The Pentagon's assured access policy depends on a second certified heavy provider besides SpaceX, and no rocket other than Vulcan is positioned to fill that role today. The owners appear to share that view. ULA closed a $1.5 billion private bond offering in August, three times its target, and named Peller permanent CEO the same month. The harder question is what ULA survives as. Our read is a government-anchored provider with a large Amazon contract, not a commercial price competitor, and that profile tends to revive the sale question Boeing and Lockheed Martin have explored more than once.
In hindsight, Amazon's procurement looks prudent. Spreading Leo across 38 Vulcan, 24 New Glenn, 24 Ariane 6, and 13 Falcon 9 launches, alongside the retiring Atlas V, was designed for exactly this kind of week. The exposure built into that mix is that 62 of those 99 rides depend on BE-4, which puts Ariane 6 and Falcon 9 on the critical path in the near term. Under the FCC's June waiver, satellites launched after July 30 also lose priority status until Leo reaches half deployment, so every lost batch carries a regulatory cost on top of the hardware.
For Blue Origin, the outcome depends on the root cause. A Centaur finding, including one in the L3Harris RL10 hydrogen engines that power that stage, would leave New Glenn largely insulated, since its upper stage runs on BE-3U engines. Supporting the investigation will still draw on the same engineers. The investigation also has an unusual org chart. Tory Bruno, who led ULA until the turn of the year, now runs national security programs at Blue Origin, the supplier of the engine under review. That gives the supplier side deep Vulcan familiarity, and it also makes a visibly independent root-cause process worth more than usual. A BE-4 finding, particularly one touching the retrofitted valve or engine shutdown control, would likely push New Glenn's return beyond the January 2027 target in Blue Origin CEO Dave Limp's memo and trigger a review of ULA's engine inventory. The engines also work differently on the two rockets (BE-4 burns roughly 299 seconds on Vulcan against roughly 191 on New Glenn), which may affect how far any finding carries over. New Glenn also has a second open item that predates the May explosion. On NG-3 in April, its upper stage placed AST SpaceMobile's BlueBird 7 in an orbit too low to operate, and AST deorbited the satellite. New Glenn's return to flight therefore has to close two investigations, not one.
That leaves Rocket Lab's upcoming Neutron. The current Electron lifts about 300 kg to LEO against 22,800 kg for an expendable Falcon 9, roughly 1 to 76, or about 1 to 58 against Falcon 9 in reusable mode. Neutron is designed for 13,000 kg with a downrange booster landing, about 43 Electrons, or roughly three quarters of a reusable Falcon 9. Rocket Lab now targets a 2027 debut, with a date expected only after component testing wraps in the first quarter. Its 16-mission backlog starts customer flights in late 2028, and the next open slots are in the 2030s. On the 2026 pace, Falcon 9 flies about 38 non-Starlink missions a year, so 16 Neutron missions spread across 2028 to 2030 would be on the order of 13 percent of that pool. Notably, the new $70 million base price sits close to Falcon 9's list price. Neutron is selling availability, not a lower price per kilogram.
Looking Ahead
The key trend we'll be monitoring is how Starship's progress feeds back into everyone else's pricing. Roughly three quarters of Falcon 9 flights this year have carried Starlink, yet the fleet is running behind 2025's record of 165 launches and went through a multi-week Starlink gap this fall. Our read, which SpaceX has not confirmed, is that part of that slowdown reflects Starlink shifting its deployment toward V3 on Starship. As that shift continues, the Falcon 9 capacity does not disappear. It becomes available to outside customers. That would ease the very scarcity Rocket Lab cited when it raised Neutron's base price, and it may give SpaceX room to price Falcon 9 aggressively just as Neutron arrives. Starship is the predator in this market, but its first meal may be Neutron's pricing power rather than any rival rocket. Over the next 90 days, ULA's preliminary root cause will largely decide whether BE-4 is implicated, and that answer in turn sets the clock on New Glenn's return, with Rocket Lab's first quarter testing and SpaceX's next double-catch attempt close behind. Our expectation is that by the time Neutron flies its first customer mission in late 2028, constellation buyers will be negotiating against Falcon 9's price rather than its availability.
Stephen Sopko | Analyst-in-Residence – Semiconductors & Deep Tech
Stephen Sopko is an Analyst-in-Residence specializing in semiconductors and the deep technologies powering today’s innovation ecosystem. With decades of executive experience spanning Fortune 100, government, and startups, he provides actionable insights by connecting market trends and cutting-edge technologies to business outcomes.
Stephen’s expertise in analyzing the entire buyer’s journey, from technology acquisition to implementation, was refined during his tenure as co-founder and COO of Palisade Compliance, where he helped Fortune 500 clients optimize technology investments. His ability to identify opportunities at the intersection of semiconductors, emerging technologies, and enterprise needs makes him a sought-after advisor to stakeholders navigating complex decisions.



















